During the past few years, the term
"Ethical Travel" has entered the globe-trotter's lexicon. It's an
easy term to define. Ethical travel is simply mindful travel: an awareness
of our impact as we explore the world. Travel is now the biggest industry
on Earth - even bigger than oil - and the economic clout of travelers
is enormous. Which countries should we visit? Where do we spend our
money once we get there? How do our interactions with our hosts support
international goodwill, and promote cross-cultural understanding?
The way we answer these questions has a real influence on the environment,
human rights, and the way our home country is viewed abroad.
Each year, millions of travelers pack their bags and head for the
usual destinations: Paris, Bangkok, San Francisco, Rio, Beijing. While
Ethical Traveler sees all travel as a potentially positive force,
we'd like to see people step off the beaten path. Many developing
countries, in their efforts to woo travelers, are making noble attempts
to preserve their natural assets, create a user-friendly infrastructure,
and build an economy where their citizens share the benefits of tourist
revenue. By bringing our commerce to such places we encourage their
efforts, and inspire neighboring countries to support these values
as well.
Ethical Traveler is pleased to announce our 2008 list of The Developing
World's 10 Best Ethical Destinations. The winners, in alphabetical
order, are:
Argentina
Bolivia
Bulgaria
Chile
Costa Rica
Croatia
Estonia*
Namibia
Nicaragua
South Africa
How the list is created
To create this list, Ethical Traveler conducts a study of the world's
70+ developing nations, from Albania to Zimbabwe. We begin our research
by looking at three general categories: Environmental Protection,
Social Welfare, and Human Rights.
For all of these categories, we look at information past and present
so that we may understand not only the current state of a country,
but its forward path. This helps us select countries that are actively
improving the state of their people and environment.
Environmental protection
In evaluating each country's
level of responsible environmental protection, we looked at clear
indicators of environmental health, preservation of resources, and
cultivation of beneficial, sustainable practices. Our two main resources
are the Socioeconomic Data and Applications Center (SEDAC) Environmental
Performance Index and the SEDAC Environmental Sustainability Index.
Both are joint initiatives between the Yale Center for Environmental
Law & Policy and Columbia University's Center for International Earth
Science Information Network. The former uses indicators focused on:
(i) reducing environmental stresses on human health and
(ii) promoting ecosystem vitality and sound natural resource management.
1. Costa Rica
scored particularly well, with a very high level of overall environmental
health, excellent water resources, biodiversity, air quality, and
sustainable energy. The latter index studies indicators of sustainability,
resilience, and vulnerability on a national scale.
2. The combination
of the two indices allowed us to measure these countries against 427
separate indicators of environmental responsibility. Croatia, with
its large percentage of protected eco-regions, was a top performer
on this index. Also noteworthy was Argentina, with outstanding water
quality and sustainable forestry practices.
Social welfare
Another critical point we consider
is the social welfare of each country's citizens and visitors. Quantifying
this is not a straightforward task. In order to gain the clearest
picture of the situation, we combine well-respected resources with
our own country-by-country research.
One telling indicator of social welfare is the mortality rate of young
children. To understand mortality rates past and present, we researched
statistics provided by UNICEF. Bolivia and South Africa had the lowest
rates of infant mortality of our Top 10 countries. To measure the
civil liberties enjoyed by citizens of each country, we used the Freedom
in the World 2007 Report from Freedom House. Estonia and Bulgaria
stood out in this ranking, with Chile and Costa Rica also receiving
the highest possible score.
To gauge other important issues such as access to safe drinking water,
sustainable water management, responsible sanitation practices, and
agricultural management, we referred to the 2006 Human Development
Report, compiled by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).
Perhaps surprisingly, Namibia was top-ranked in this category.
Human rights
A number of sources were used to evaluate each
country's human rights record. Respected sources like Amnesty International,
Human Rights Watch, Reporters Without Borders, and Freedom House were
consulted to understand the challenges each nation has to address.
Freedom House gave Estonia, Chile, and Costa Rica the highest rating
in civil liberties. Reporters Without Borders found Argentina to have
a very high level of Freedom of the Press, with Nicaragua close behind.
Every country has human rights issues-but it was important for us
to see efforts being made towards improving known situations and the
preservation of basic human rights for all.
General trends and conclusions
Notably, half of the Top 10 Destinations are in Latin America, perhaps
following the sustainable tourism lead of highly popular, top-ranked
Costa Rica. Three other countries - Belize, Peru, and Ecuador - receive
honorable mentions as well. On the other hand, not a single Asian
country made it to the Top 10. Runaway development, human rights abuses,
and a lack of strong environmental policy kept them all off the list
this year. Surprising, though, three Eastern European countries made
the final list. We believe this bodes well for the future of these
emerging nations. We're also excited to have an additional African
country - Namibia - appear on the list.
Several countries that made our previous Top Ethical Destinations
list (in 2005) were omitted this time around. Our last list, for example,
strongly encouraged travelers to bring their commerce to tsunami-ravaged
Sri Lanka. During the past several years, however, the sectarian violence
on the island has grown to alarming levels, with tensions between
the Tamils and Sinhalese running high. The government has failed to
rebuild coastal communities quickly, and corruption is rampant - with
reports of large, foreign-owned hotels encroaching on traditional
fishing beaches. For these reasons Sri Lanka is unfortunately no longer
on our list.
Kenya was also on our previous list, but the country's tragic descent
into ethnic violence, following December's contested elections, makes
a travel recommendation impossible. Also absent this year is Belize.
Large-scale construction in sensitive areas, and waste run-off from
large hotels is contributing to the destruction of the country's coral
reefs and mangroves. Until the government takes sterner steps to protect
its ocean environment, we cannot include Belize on our "most recommended"
list.
Travelers are often surprised that Bhutan is not one of our Top Ethical
Destinations. Despite its sublime natural beauty and extraordinary
commitment to preserving the environment, the highly nationalistic
kingdom is still plagued by human rights issues. These concerns include
the fate of more than 100,000 Bhutanese of Nepalese descent, who were
expelled from country in the early 1990s and still live in refugee
camps along the Bhutan/West Bengal/Nepal border.
None of the countries on this year's Ethical Destinations list are
perfect, and two in particular come with caveats. Though Nicaragua
is committed to fair trade and sustainable tourism, and maintains
very low CO2 emissions, homosexuality remains criminalized. Normally,
this is a deal-breaker for us; but the law is not enforced, and is
the subject of wide protest. We sincerely hope that our vote of confidence
will help persuade Nicaragua's leaders to repeal this backward law.
South Africa received high marks for supporting eco-friendly, community-based
tourism ventures, as well as for species protection and vigilance
against poaching. The country, however, has a huge rich/poor gap,
and a high crime rate. Travelers should be mindful of the dangers,
and stay informed about which areas to avoid.
We sincerely hope that travelers will refer to this list when planning
their 2008 journeys. By visiting the countries mentioned here, we
"vote with our wings"-sending a signal that travelers are aware of
where their money is going, and willing to support nations that care
about the environment, human rights, and the global community. To
learn more about Ethical Traveler-and to join our alliance of members
from more than 60 countries-please visit our website at www.ethicaltraveler.org.
By Jeff Greenwald & Christy Hoove, published on EthicalTraveler.org
Bookmark or Share
